Rustic homemade pumpkin spice soap! Handcrafted with all natural Ingredients. Pumpkin Spice - Sweet, Spiced, & Warm. Who doesn't love Pumpkin Spice? To start, I slow-roast a local, organic pie pumpkin, and then finely purée the meaty, delicious flesh, and blend it into this soap. I add dashes of real spices and scent the soap with cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, ginger, and then also clove and cinnamon essential oils to give it a true, complex pumpkin-pie aroma.